Controverisal Play and Topic in Early Childhood Education

As adults we have more knowledge and experience of the world than that of children, because of this we tend to view and analyze children’s play based upon our learned beliefs and values. However, this sometimes brings us to a crossroads when children begin to show interest in something that seems “wrong”, “dangerous”, or “against our beliefs”. What do we do? This blog will, explore topics of children’s play that make us feel uncomfortable and give suggestions on how we can take a step back to figure out why and how to support their learning and understanding.

Monday, February 26, 2018

Let the Children Play (Part 1): It's Their Right!


CHILDREN HAVE THE RIGHT TO PLAY AND SEEK INFORMATION OF ALL KINDS, EVEN IF IT MAKES US ADULTS FEEL UNCOMFORTABLE.

I have done many workshops about play and when I ask the participants, “Why have you stopped, restricted, or banned children’s play?” they usually state one of the following: the children were going to get hurt, the behaviour was going to get out of control, the behaviour was disrupting the learning environment because it had escalated into loud and rough types of play; or the focus of the play promoted an inappropriate concept, seemed violent, and/or was aggressive. The participants who admitting feeling comfortable with more controversial play themes were still worried about the judgment of others, whether it was parents, coworkers or others in the community. They were worried that others would view the play, they were letting the children do, as wrong and/or they would tell a higher authority about it. Such as, CFS, their Directors, or their Coordinators.

In truth, these are all valid reasons why caregivers want to stop play. I myself have stopped play for these same reasons. However, I have realized that it is not respectful to the children and their right to play.

This right to play has been clearly defined by the U.N. Convention on the Rights of the Child. Since Canada is one of many countries that has signed the Convention, I feel that it is our duty as Early Childhood Educators, parents, and community members to help children maintain and fight for those rights. According to Article 13.1 in the Convention:

THE CHILD SHALL HAVE THE RIGHT TO FREEDOM OF EXPRESSION; THIS RIGHT SHALL INCLUDE FREEDOM TO SEEK, RECEIVE AND IMPART INFORMATION AND IDEAS OF ALL KINDS, REGARDLESS OF FRONTIERS, EITHER ORALLY, IN WRITING OR IN PRINT, IN THE FORM OF ART, OR THROUGH ANY OTHER MEDIA OF THE CHILD'S CHOICE. 

By this definition, a child has the right to express themselves though play, and if it is a concept or topic that is a little controversial (e.g. gun play, death, marriage equality), it is important that we help children seek honest, unbiased information about the topic based on their age and understanding…even if it makes us uncomfortable. By doing so we will help them learn how to form their own opinions about what they believe. For example, is it okay to hunt animals? There are many sides to this topic and all should be explored. You may be surprised with what they think or how much they know about the topic. As an adult, you probably already have your opinion on this topic, but can you put that aside so children can learn to make their own?

Not only is it a child’s right to play but also to seek information of all kinds. We should not conceal any topic or type of play if the child is interested. But what happens when we do? The child will try to understand about this topic through their play, but without us knowing. They will try to hide their interest, which will either make them really good at deceiving us and/or they will continue to figure it out with the feeling of guilt for doing so. They will also feel they will not be able to discuss the topic with you. Gun play is one example of such a topic.

Before starting a ‘gun play project’ with a group of 5 and 6 year old children, I had seen a few children making guns out of Lego. When I asked them if they were making guns, they quickly said, “No, it’s a laser”. Even though I knew they were deceiving me, it closed the discussion because they were scared they were going to get in trouble.  This really bothered me that they did not feel comfortable talking to me about their interest, and I knew that they would learn more about guns by other means. This was when I realized that I needed to change so they could use me as a resource for their learning. I needed to follow the child’s interest even if the topic was something we commonly restrict like gun play. By doing so we could research their interest together and really look at all sides of the topic. What do they want to know? What do they believe? What do others believe? And why?  I could help them become even better researchers and help them figure out what they wanted to learn.

LET THE CHILDREN PLAY, SUPPORT THEIR RIGHTS AND BE THE RESOURCE THEY NEED.

“Canada became a signatory to the U.N. Convention on the rights of the child on May 28, 1990 and it was ratified on December 13, 1991.”

Stay tuned for: Let the Children Play (Part 2): It’s a Need

No comments:

Post a Comment